The Tolcarne Inn

Newlyn, Penzance, Cornwall, TR18 5PR

Higher Member

Location, location, location dictates both the ethos and food at this historic maritime pub. The Tolcarne Inn’s proximity to Newlyn Harbour – where approximately 50 species of fish are regularly brought ashore – means chef-owner Ben Tunnicliffe gets the pick of the catch within hours of it being landed.

Naturally this generates a daily evolving menu and, once the seafood is caught and dishes designed, the offering is chalked up on the pub’s blackboard. This on-the-fly intuitive style of cooking suits the chef.

Ben enjoys serious creds on the Cornish food scene – he held a Michelin star at The Abbey in Penzance in previous years – but is happiest in the unpretentious surroundings of this tucked-away inn.

His instinctively prepared seafood packs a flavour punch in dishes like red mullet with lemon-glazed salsify and fennel, ray wing with smoked-ham croquettes, cider and grain mustard, or the more unusual weaver fish with scallop-roe taramasalata and cucumber chutney.

Being a pub, quality drinks are equally as important so The Tolcarne serves seafood-friendly local ales and ciders alongside wines that have been specifically chosen to complement the culinary direction.

Trencherman’s tip

Soak up the pub’s immense history when crossing the threshold: the lintel above the entrance door marks its date of construction in 1717.

About The Tolcarne Inn

3 course dinner from: £53

Chef(s):Ben Tunnicliffe

Seats: 35

The definitive guide to the South West's most exceptional restaurants

Since 1992, we've revealed the most exquisite restaurants, dining pubs and foodie hotels in Cornwall, Devon, Dorset, Bath, Somerset and the Cotswolds through the highly rated dining guide.

More Trencherman's restaurants in